Justice

I believe strongly in justice and generally it works very well in the UK. But there are cases where justice has not been well served. Particularly in the process leading to the Courts. I work free of charge to any innocence project and will happily assist and advise any person or group who does not have the means or funds to stand their ground. I do not look for "angles". I am only interested in the facts. If the case against you is well founded then I will say so. So be prepared.

If you are a legal representative then please contact me on David.Townsend@andrew-moore.com

Tuesday, 5 January 2010

The burden (standard) of proof

The burden of proof is the obligation on a party to establish the facts in issue in a case to the required degree of certainty (the standard of proof) in order to prove their case.
It is rarely possible for any investigation, fire or otherwise, to be concluded with 100% certainty. There is thus always an element of doubt. The question is of course at what level of proof is it reasonable to atribute blame. The consequenses of any conviction are of course severe and life-changing for the parties involved: Incarceration at Criminal Court, loss of livelihood at Civil Court.
Cases are not normally concluded on the basis of one single element alone but expert reports can be pivotal.
So if 100% proof is not attainable what level of proof IS acceptable?
90%?, 80%?, 51%?
The answer is: None of the above.
It is not practical to define proof as a percentage. After all, in terms of the actual evidence what would be the tangible difference between 80% and 81% proof?. It is entirely subjective and open to wide interpretation and critisism.

There are in fact two levels of proof: One for Criminal Law and one for Civil Law.
The burden, or standard, of proof for Criminal cases is "Beyond all reasonable doubt"
The burden, or standard, of proof for Civil cases is "the balance of probabilities"
There is a considerable difference.
In criminal cases the level of proof is reasonably clear but in Civil cases, technically, all that is required is a level of proof beyond 50%! That is an extremely low basis on which to make potentially life-changing decisions but it can happen. In practise, in insurance-related and some other civil matters, there are legal directions that cases should be considered proved only with a significantly higher level of proof than 50+%. It has not been defined but only suggested that proof should be near to 75%. This is reasonable.
But what about cases that do not go to the Courts. Insurance claims are a civil matter and adjusters may refuse a claim on the basis of proof considerably less than 75%. These decisions should be challenged vigorously.
I have successfully represented a number of claimants under these circumstances.

No comments:

Post a Comment